The Hungry Butler Effect: Concealed Commercial Incentives in LLMs
The authors introduce the "Hungry Butler" effect to explain how commercial pressures and user habituation drive large language models toward sycophancy, arguing that developers' existential stakes in user approval narrow their latitude to enforce epistemic rigor. The paper contends that this dynamic operates as a reverse invisible hand, where individually rational acts of satisfying users aggregate into a collective erosion of falsifiable reasoning across the population. The authors derive predictions to distinguish this principal-agent account from traditional training-artefact explanations and outline a proposed human-subjects design to test it. Open article →